Rolo Cookies for Project Pinterest with ILYMTC

It’s another fun week for linking up with I Love You More Than Carrots for ‘Project Pinterest’  Last week I reported on the delicious and easy Ham and Cheese Quinoa Quiches I made from Pinterest. This week I wanted to do something different and my friend recently pinned these cookies, The Rolo Cookies! I thought I would surprise her and make her them for her birthday today!

I cheated on these cookies and used a boxed cookie mix. They didn’t come out as well at the photo, that’s for sure and they were actually kind of difficult to make. Even with a boxed mix, which was kind of strange. I mixed the box mix together and put it in the fridge overnight becuase it was far too goopy to wrap the dough around the Rolo.

If you want to use a boxed cookie mix, you just need some Rolos (don’t mind the one that is missing the wrapper, B had to snack before I even started…) A stick of butter and one egg.


Mixed together, here’s the lovely mix. I should have ‘rolled’ the dough in the cinnamon sugar mix, but I wasn’t patient and it was at 11 pm at night.

This was not going to be rolled around a Rolo, no way no how. Put it in the fridge overnight to get it to harden up and it helped a ton.

Pat down the dough into a little oval pancake. The only thing that’s hard about these cookies is that you need a lot of dough to cover the Rolo. They aren’t little candies, and so therefore the cookies are HUGE.

Then you just form a ball around the Rolo candy. It was much harder than I expected, so they better taste amazing. :)

The other reason they have to be so big is because if you don’t have dough under the Rolo, it melts onto the baking sheet and then the cookies don’t come off as easily. They didn’t come out as well as I wanted them too, but a cookie is a cookie right? :) I probably won’t make these again with all the little tricks to these. They just need so much dough to go all the way around the Rolo! I don’t get how in the Pinterest photo they are all such small cookies. Oh well! They still tasted pretty good and I’m sure my friend will like them :)

Happy Monday!


in Uncategorized

7 Responses to Rolo Cookies for Project Pinterest with ILYMTC

  1. Kristi says:

    You are right, a cookie is a cookie! I may not make them but I sure would eat them!

  2. Ed says:

    Mmmmm those cookies look fantastic…sheesh I need to do some baking, or give my wife the idea to do so!

  3. AP says:

    So.. Rolos used to be my favorite candy. I can’t remember the last time I had one- so I may just need to play around with this recipe a little! Thanks so much for linking up.. BTW .. your Quinoa Quiches were a HIT on Pinterest last week.. They are STILL being repinned! Yum! ;)

  4. Nina says:

    I love you my little cookie. A cookie is a cookie is a cookie. #lovielife. Ounce ounce ounceeee

  5. Jess says:

    So true a cookie is a cookie!!’ look yummy!!!

  6. Laina says:

    Try them again with the mini rolls. They come in a bag and you don’t have to unwrap anything! Let us know if you bake them again.

  7. Laina says:

    Sorry, I meant mini rolos!!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>